Many wonder about losing German Citizenship and ask themselves: can German citizenship be revoked? This question has gained renewed attention with the introduction of Germany’s new citizenship law, which aims to modernize the country’s approach to naturalization and dual citizenship. Let’s explore the various ways German citizenship can be lost or revoked, including recent changes and historical contexts.
Understanding German Citizenship Loss
The loss or revocation of German citizenship involves complex legal frameworks. Although Germany has been cautious about revoking citizenship for historical reasons, several circumstances can still lead to the loss or revocation of German citizenship. Let’s explore these in detail:
1. Acquisition of Foreign Citizenship
Historically, this has been the most common reason for losing German citizenship.
- Current Policy (Until June 27, 2024): If you willingly apply for and receive a foreign citizenship, you automatically lose your German citizenship according to paragraph 25 of the German citizenship act.
- Exceptions:
- Loss can be avoided by obtaining a special permit (“Beibehaltungsgenehmigung“) before naturalization in a foreign country.
- Since August 28, 2007, German citizenship is no longer lost if you acquire citizenship of an EU member state or Switzerland.
- Acquiring another citizenship automatically at birth does not impact German citizenship.
2. Voluntary Service in Foreign Military Forces
Since January 1, 2000, German citizens who voluntarily join the armed forces of a country other than Germany, of which they are also a citizen, without prior permission from the Federal Ministry for Defense, automatically lose their German citizenship (paragraph 28 of the German citizenship act).
- Important Update: Since July 6, 2011, permission is considered automatically given for citizens of NATO member states joining the armed forces of those countries.
3. Voluntary Renunciation
German citizens who also hold citizenship of another country can renounce their German citizenship by declaration. This process ensures that individuals have the freedom to choose their allegiance while preventing statelessness.
4. Adoption by Foreign Parents
Since January 1, 1977, minors adopted by non-German parents may lose their German citizenship if the adoption automatically makes them citizens of their adopted parents’ country and they are no longer legally related to their German parent(s).
5. Long-term Residence Abroad (Historical)
German citizens who had their permanent residence abroad for more than 10 years before 1914 automatically lost their German citizenship unless they registered in the “Konsulatsmatrikel” (consular register) of the German consulate. This is particularly relevant for tracing German citizenship to ancestors who emigrated before 1904.
6. Historical Nazi-era Laws
Between January 30, 1933, and May 8, 1945, two significant laws deprived many Germans of their citizenship:
- The “Law on the Revocation of Naturalizations and the Deprivation of the German Citizenship” (July 14, 1933)
- The “Eleventh Decree to the Law on the Citizenship of the Reich” (November 25, 1941), which primarily affected Jews living outside Germany
Individuals who lost their German citizenship due to these laws, along with most of their descendants, can apply for renaturalization under current German law.
Master the Einbürgerungstest
The New German Citizenship Law and Its Implications
The new German citizenship law, which came into effect in 2023, introduces significant changes to the German naturalization process and dual citizenship regulations. While the law generally makes it easier for foreigners to obtain German citizenship and allows for broader acceptance of dual citizenship, it maintains many of the fundamental principles governing citizenship loss.
Dual Citizenship and Revocation
Under the new law, Germany now officially recognizes dual citizenship for all nationalities, removing previous restrictions that often forced individuals to choose between their original citizenship and German citizenship. This change raises an important question: can Germany revoke citizenship if an individual holds dual citizenship?
The answer is nuanced. While holding dual citizenship itself is not grounds for revocation, the circumstances that could lead to citizenship loss still apply, regardless of whether an individual holds one or multiple citizenships. However, the new law provides more flexibility and protection for dual citizens.
A Balanced Approach to Citizenship
IIn conclusion, although specific circumstances can lead to the revocation or loss of German citizenship, the process is rare and carefully regulated. As Germany continues to evolve its approach to citizenship, the question “can German citizenship be revoked?” remains relevant, reminding us of the delicate balance between national security, individual rights, and international obligations in our interconnected world.
The new citizenship law, while expanding opportunities for naturalization and dual citizenship, aims to provide clearer guidelines and protections for German citizens, reflecting Germany’s commitment to adapting its policies to the realities of a globalized world.
German Citizenship Test App
